I have to admit I'm biased in this regard. Although I was raised rigidly Roman Catholic, I had the wonderful opportunities of attending a Roman Catholic private school and a private liberal arts school which have exposed me to different walks of life...well, at least people of different beliefs, since many were rich white kids. But I believe in the validity of all paths. I've been thinking and reading lately about fundamentalist forms of Christianity and would like to learn more. Of course, it's virtually impossible to form a dialogue with anyone whose belief system declares only one belief valid, but I'm interested to know a Christian fundamentalist's answer to the questions I'm proposing (or even from those who follow a belief system based on the infallibity of certain doctrines or texts):
1.) How does one know that the Bible is the one true source of all things? I don't mean this to be insulting, but how does one actually find out that everything in the Bible is true? Even as a strict Roman Catholic growing up, I knew it was just a book. Of course, I've heard many conservative Protestants' criticisms of Roman Catholicism and how it's not as Bible-heavy as they'd like. But back to the question. Really think about this. How do you know all of it is the Word of God? You can't just say because the Bible says so because the question itself is about the Bible itself! Or is it because you're told? That doesn't really satisfy me either, but if it is, so be it. It's a simple question, but it's one that really just hit me a few days ago, the process of knowing things. Maybe a fundamentalist couldn't answer that question because logic--which is only one way of coming to know things--does not apply to their beliefs...and that's not necessarily a bad thing because their way of thinking is just as legitimate as someone else's (logic is a system in itself, and it's important to realize that so we're not indiscriminately bashing others; we'd be just as "bad" if we believed in the infallibility of logic, too).
2.) How do you reconcile the history of the Bible and Christianity with your place in the world today? Allow me to elaborate, but forgive me if sound too cryptic. There are many histories--an interpretation of historical events written down by Hitler would look different than one written by Churchill, or one by an Indian historian would look different than a Peruvian, because both hold very different opinions, each informed by very unique experiences. How do all the archaeological, anthropological, and historical discoveries inform your beliefs (no one lives--and no one can--live in a vacuum outside of all the information being uncovered today)? For example, Christianity evolved from a minority sect of Judaism intot eh state religion of the Roman Empire, further adopted by emerging figureheads descended from once pagan Indo-European tribes after the vacuum created by the fall of Rome. The Roman Catholic Church during the Middle Ages, then also a political power (now relegated to the status of a world-wide moral arbiter--still a powerful position), was the sole authority on dogma, interpreting the Bible (which itself was a product of not only God, but human hands--there was indeed a select process of editing out and adding back in certain apochryphal texts...but it's to be remembered that some people back then took the Book of Thomas and all the rest just as seriously since there was no "book" available, it was oral) for centuries until the 1500s. Christian Fundamentalism, which really didn't take hold until recently (mid/late 19th century) in the U.S., was influenced by aspects of American history, from the Piety Movement, Puritans, the Great Awakening, and the complication of modern society. How does a Christian Fundamentalist reconcile their beliefs with these apparent facts that Christianity was once a minority religion, was once totally under the juristiction of the Roman Catholic Church which, like it or not, influenced present-day Protestant beliefs for holding onto Christianity as a whole for so long, and that there exists social and cultural reasons and explanations for why there beliefs took hold recently in America, as well as for the historical transformation of the Bible as an historical text? Check out James Marsden's American Fundamentalism for more information; it's good for both non-Christian fundamentalists and Christian fundamentalists to read about an unreadily tolerated group in mainstream American culture and to inform their own beliefs on a socio-cultural level.
3.) After talking about the reconciliation of belief and the process of inevitable evolution of those beliefs over time through socio-cultural factors, back to the debate over the infallibility of the Bible. So everything in the Bible is supposedly true and all is well if we just follow what it says, right? But how does the process of interpreting factor in? Hermeneutics, the philosophy of interpretation, is what we're dealing with. Obviously, no one is the same person, and thank God this is so. We're all products of different experiences that will inevitable influence the interpretations we make, no matter how "true" the verses are. And in regards to interpreting sacred, ancient texts, this is especially true since the verses are generally cryptic and vague. Some of the interpretations that preachers make may seem logical ("Though shalt not kill" transferring to not talking shit about your friends), others not so much, but they are still making interpretations and all will be influenced by your experience; there is no one "true" interpretation. It's impossible! Sorry, Pope.
4.) In the same vein as above, how can you say someone is going to Hell? Sure, it may say it in the Bible, but after that discussion on hermeneutics and how everybody interprets things differently, think about this: can you really know the mind of God? God is infinite! I think both of us can agree on that. So what if someone calls God by some other name if that's all they know or that's how they were brought up and they lead a good, respectable life. How do you know God will punish them?
5.) On a different note, I'd like to ask someone about Armageddon. Many millenialist Christians say that the end of the world is near, the Rapture is coming, and Jesus Christ is coming back. But people have been saying that for ages! Hurricane Katrina, the War and Iraq, and moral reprobation, three of the most often cited evidence for the nearing of Armageddon, can't be as bad as the Black Plague, which eliminated one-third of the population of Europe in the High Middle Ages, the Napoleonic, Crimean, 30 Years, 100 Years, or any wars, and the decadence of the late Roman Empire--which all happened after Christianity flourished. What makes you think now. Why do you interpret recents events to be evidence of the end of the world when regarding the historical context? I hope someday I could have a discussion, but it may prove impossible. From those I've encountered, they interpret every discussion as a Crusade to uphold their beliefs, turning the other cheek as Jesus said, and see their small numbers not as evidence of their marginality but as a supposed status as the spiritual elite.
I realize many of my arguments the average Joe Fundamentalist-Christian doesn't think about. I'm just curious to see how they think about their beliefs when they regard these points without readily dismissing them. I don't believe every Fundamentalist Christian to be a poor, Midwest, uninformed, uneducated hick. I'm sure many are just as intelligent as I. It's just when they don't try to inform their beliefs, when they're afraid to look at things and think about them that I get frustrated. Which I'm sure will happen, but there are plenty of Wiccans, Buddhists, Muslims, etc. who do that, too. I tried to keep a neutral tone and apologize if I offended anyone, because that was not the intention.
Tuesday, June 17, 2008
Thoughts on and Questions about Christian Fundamentalism
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

No comments:
Post a Comment