Thursday, June 19, 2008

Villa & Richter play Scriabin's Sonatas 4 & 5

Over the past year, I've dedicated myself to learning late nineteenth/early twentieth century Russian composer Alexander Nikolayevich Scriabin's (Александр Николаевич Скрябин, 1872-1915) Piano Sonatas Nos. 4 and 5. My piano professor encouraged me to learn the fifth in Spring '07, and not only did learning it do wonders for my technique, but it opened me to an often overlooked composer and a whole new world of classical composition. At that time, I was getting bored with the Rachmaninovs, Debussys, and Chopins; nothing gave me the chills anymore. But then I happened on Sasha, here. Although now I realize I like almost anything from the late nineteenth to early twentieth centuries, I began plucking out Scriabin's Sonata No. 5 and it seemed like it came from out of nowhere, something that seemed contemporary, but actually came from over 100 years ago. Stuff like that really gives me the chills. In actuality, Scriabin's music comes from some place entirely different than any compositional era.


Music is the most abstract of arts. It is no wonder, then, that Scriabin made the connection between mysticism and music. Although already a piano and compositional student when he became enamored with Theosophy, the pieces from his Middle Period (roughly 1903/5 to perhaps 1910) reflected a conscious change in incorporating his mystical ideas into his compositions. Historians usually group him in the "Symbolist" category, a trans-European intellectual tradition with no self-proclaimed label beginning in France with authors like Baudelaire (his later works) and Mallarmé. Those that followed the Symbolist aesthetic attempted to convey absolute truths through indirect means, like poetry and music, which were believed the only means to do so. To me, the movement was like a dark, mystcal, expressionist version of Romanticism, if that helps. Scriabin sought to express the sexual side of Nature and Creation in his music. Those subtle, divine archetypes of Male and Female forces are reduced to mystical abstraction in his music, but surprisingly, they are recognizable, perhaps by a process of inutterable mystical understanding. Scriabin was also a self-professed synathaesiate, associated various keys with different colors. Although scholars assumed his system was consciously contrived (which was in vogue at the time) with no mystical experience involved, borrowing ideas from Newton's Opticks, it reflects a conscious decision on the part of the composer to incorporate ideas of a universe united by various correspondences. He planned a performance of his unfinished Mysterium to be held in the Himalayas, the world seat of mysticism, with bells hung on clouds and music by the wind as the world dissolved into music. Absolutely beautiful. He straddled the line between genius and insanity.


Although his early works copied a style reminiscent of Chopin and Liszt and his later works reflect an inarticulate, purely dissonant style (he became a little too enamored with his mystical leanings), the works from his Middle Period are the most enjoyable and original. This chornology roughly follows the evolution of his Piano Sonatas. The Fourth marked the beginning of this period and the Sixth, the end, but they're all sexily ecstatic. Sonata No. 4, a two movement work, opens up with a quaint first theme with sexy (it's an appropriate word in this case) chromatics and harmonies. A recapitulation of the first theme, still in the first movement, has twinkling keys in the higher register, like little twinkling stars. The movement ends on a cute, pretty chord and immediately precedes into the jumpy second movement; my present piano professor thought of it as child's playground dance. Around 4:15 there is another recapitulation of the first theme, except it is as if it is soaring...I can't describe it in words quite exactly, but it's as if an eagle is soaring over a landscape... It's worthy to note that Scriabin requires a lot of the pianist, as the dense layers of fast fingering around 4:45 attests. Throughout the entire piece, there are schizophrenic jumps from theme to theme, dynamic to dynamic, register to register; this dichotomy intensifies toward the end around the 5 minute mark, but it reconciles itself--like the mating of the polar universal male and female principles--after a leading up sexy, leading chords into a final orgiastic, jubilant climax of the first theme.





Like Sonata 4, Sonata No. 5 has tons of sexy, ecstatic chords. It's only one movement, but the organization is quite like the fourth sonata. The opening is completely dissonant, reminding me of primeval forces of chaos of creation, trailing off into infinity. Then comes a distant, ephemeral, ambient introduction of the first theme. When I play this section, I feel like I'm the Creator playing around with my tools of Creation. It finally lets loose into another thematic section with a gorgeous, yet simple bassline and a jumpy, but antagonistic treble with some of the hardest jumps known in standard piano repetoire (Richter, who incidentally plays this version, described the piece as the hardest in standard piano repetoire). The many different themes are balanced by a jumpy triplet motivic figure; it burns brightly, although subtly in schizophrenic switching between theme and figure around 2:30. They're like the omnipresent, buzzing forces of creation. The third theme introduced around 2:30 is sexy and mysterious, introducing one of Scriabin's original synthetic chord creations which, in the key of C, is made of the notes C, E, F#, A, Bb, and D, intended to bring about mystical transcendence. At 4:00, Scriabin drags the listener through yet more recapitulations of the first themes through a series of ecstatic climaxes, a favorite compositional technique of his. After the magical, whimsical weavings of the left hand around 6:00, there is another recapitulation of the sexy third theme with the triplet figure serving as that pervasive, schizophrenic rhythmic motif, bringing an orgiastic penultimate climax, suddenly cutting off to an echo of the second theme in the mysterious key of B. Yet more recapitulations and a final run of the omnipresent motif brings the composition to a jubilant orgasm beginning at 9:50 with blaring dissonances in the left hand at 10:20. The piece ends in chaos, a tribute to the perpetual, infinite process of Creation.





But it's not quite chaos. The crux of Scriabin's compositions and the Symbolist movement as a whole is the inherent inability to reconcile mystical experience with actual music, let alone words. Scriabin did not see that in crafting a composition there lies a pardox in which one limits the infinite in mystical experience. Nonetheless, by crafting such pieces there does exist beauty that gives me the chills and his later music, which disobeys classical rules, do not. His music, as different as it is, falls in a general Russian music aesthetic, too. I can sense the orchestrality of Rimsky-Korsakov, jumpy and chromatic melodies of Balakirev, the penchant for primitivism of Stravinsky, as well as non-Russian influences from French music and his previous beloved composers Liszt and Chopin.


My father detests the fifth sonata, which I can understand. I understand the music of Scriabin, and he, like most people do not. That probably explains his lack of popularity. Reading Scriabin's notes, I noticed similarities with subjects and the way he writes with mine. I'm beginning to incorporate some of his style into my music. Our facial structure is also somewhat the same, and his younger pictures bear a resemblance to me. Most of all, I enjoy his music and the elevated passion intrinsic to it, always rising higher and higher, not in pretty melodies, but in mystical ecstasy.

1 comment:

Rima Staines said...

Hello Bastian, thanks for visiting the Hermitage... :) glad your liked our porthole :)
what an interesting place you have here...
best wishes from Scotland
Rima